1. Definition of “Argumentative Assertion”
An “argumentative assertion” is a statement that is put forward with a forceful or disputatious tone, aiming to convince others or defend a particular point of view. It implies a claim that is likely to lead to an argument or a debate because it is presented with a certain level of contention. For example, “His argumentative assertion that the new policy was a complete failure sparked a heated discussion in the meeting.”
2. Synonyms
- Controversial Claim
- A “controversial claim” is a statement that is likely to cause disagreement or debate. For example, “The scientist's controversial claim that a certain species was not endangered went against the common belief.” It is similar to an argumentative assertion because it has the potential to stir up arguments. The difference is that a “controversial claim” may focus more on the content being controversial, while an “argumentative assertion” emphasizes the way the statement is presented - with an argumentative tone.
- Debatable Statement
- A “debatable statement” is one that can be argued about from different points of view. For example, “Whether technology is making us more isolated is a debatable statement.” This is related to an argumentative assertion as it invites discussion and debate. However, a “debatable statement” can be presented in a more neutral way, while an “argumentative assertion” is usually put forward with a stronger intention to persuade or oppose.
- Contentious Proposition
- A “contentious proposition” is a proposal or statement that is likely to cause contention. For example, “The politician's contentious proposition to raise taxes on the middle class was met with strong opposition.” It is similar to an argumentative assertion in that it is bound to create conflict. The difference is that a “contentious proposition” might imply a more formal or structured argument, such as a proposal in a political or academic setting, while an “argumentative assertion” can be a more general statement made in any context.
- Disputatious Affirmation
- A “disputatious affirmation” is an assertion that is made in a quarrelsome or argument - provoking way. For example, “Her disputatious affirmation that her team was the best without any objective evidence led to a rivalry with other teams.” It is very close to an argumentative assertion as it emphasizes the argument - provoking nature of the statement. The main difference might be that “disputatious affirmation” is a less commonly used phrase and has a more formal or perhaps old - fashioned ring to it.